Throg may not want to permanently give up his warhelm, since he won't be able to wear the a magic helm once is higher in level (but he may or may not get a helm that is a Chaos artefact). I didn't think about the possibility of having one of the rescued prisoners carry the lantern, but it does make sense. For Throg to carry a Sword of Defiance in his off-hand, he could also have Dorgath or Kelgar carry the lantern, I guess.
Arcttus hesitantly accepts Throg's warhelm and lantern. Dorgath examines the remaining items from the chest, but appears to have trouble identifying them. Kelgar helps out while Carrow stands guard...
-Dorgath identifies a Sword of Might. +1 Strength. Worth 150 gold.
-Dorgath cannot identify the crystal.
-Dorgath identifies an Elf Cloak. May ignore 1 damage from each blow that hits the wearer. Each time it absorbs damage, it rips and is destroyed on a D6 roll of 1. Worth 50 gold.
-Dorgath identifies a jeweled ornamental dagger. Useless in combat. Worth 100 gold.
-Kelgar identifies an Amulet of Fury. Contains a single use of the Invulnerability spell. Disintegrates after use. Worth 200 gold.
-Kelgar corrects Dorgath's cloak identification. Kelgar identifies a Cloak of Invisibility. The wearer may become invisibly once per adventure. Worth 200 gold. Carrow shakes his head at Dorgath's ignorance of his people. Of course it wasn't an Elf Cloak. Silly dwarf.
-Kelgar examines the dagger and points something out...
Dorgath decides that the black rock is definitely not coal. It does look similar to coal, but it's not dense enough and it seems to be too hard to be coal, in addition to the odd texture. Kelgar thinks it is not magical, but he isn't sure.
A tiny jewel in the pommel of the ornamental dagger contains what appears to be an image of a raging dwarf. He doesn't seem to notice your presence, but he is very upset about something. Wait a minute, you recognize him. He looks just like the stone warrior you saw in the middle of that room earlier...