I'll choose to add the counters, but thanks for giving me the option.
Untap, Upkeep (
Melkor moves two +1/+1 counters to the Fertilid and two +1/+1 counters to the Aerial Responder), Draw
First Main Phase
Spidey plays Inferno Titan dealing 2 damage to Bone Picker and 1 damage to the God Emperor (Forgotten Ancient gets a counter)
Combat
rokapoke attacks with Aerial Responder
Second Main Phase
rokapoke casts Youthful Knight (Ancient gets counter)
Melkor plays a Forest (puts counter on Knight with Retreat), and plays Rampaging Baloths (Ancient gets counter)
Nicol Bolas, God Emperor of Dune: 35 34? 28?
Hand: 2
Library: 43
Battlefield:
(T,T) Swamp x2
(T) Island x1
(U) Mountain x1
(U) Highland Lake (~ etb tapped. T: adds U or R to my mana pool.)
(T) Submerged Boneyard (~ etb tapped. T: adds U or B to my mana pool.)
(U)
Obelisk of Grixis (T: adds U, B, or R to my mana pool.)
(U)
Horror token (3/3)
(U)
Flametongue Kavu (4/2; when ~ etb, it deals 4 damage to target creature.)
(S)
Bone Picker (3/2; ~ costs 3 less to cast if a creature died this turn. Flying, deathtouch.) (Dead?)
(S)
Horror token (3/3; attacks Melkor if able.)
(S)
Horror token (3/3; attacks Spidey if able.)
(S)
Horror token (3/3; attacks Rokapoke if able.)
Graveyard: Swamp,
Overseer of the Damned, Mountain,
Sudden Demise, Bone Picker, Doom Blade
Exile:
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Melkor: 20
Hand: 1
Library: 47
Battlefield:
(T,T) Island x2
(T,T,T) Forest x3
(T) Woodland Stream (~ ETB tapped.; T: Add U or G to my mana pool)
Retreat to Kazandu (Landfall-Whenever a land ETB under my control, choose one-
- Put a +1/+1 cts on target creature
- I gain 2 life
(U)
Fertilid (
4/4 from ctrs; ~ ETB with two +1/+1 ctrs on it.; 1G, Remove a +1/+1 ctr from ~: Target player searches his library for a basic land card and puts it onto the battlefield tapped. Then that player shuffles his library)
(U)
Forgotten Ancient (3
/6 from ctrs; Whenever a player casts a spell, I may put a +1/+! ctr on ~.; At the beginning of my upkeep, I may move any number of +1/+1 ctrs from ~ onto other creatures) *4 +1/+1 ctr*
(S)
Rampaging Baloths (6/6, Trample, Landfall - Whenever a land etb under your control, you may put a 4/4 green Beast creature token onto the battlefield)
Graveyard: Ior Ruin Expedition, Vines of the Recluse
Exile:
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Spidey: 20
Hand: 2
Library: 45
Battlefield:
(T,T,T,T,T,T) Mt x6
(U)
Obsidian Fireheart (4/4; 1RR: Put a blaze ctr on target land without a blaze ctr on it. For as long as that land has a blaze ctr on it, it has "At the beginning of my upkeep, this land deals 1 dmg to me." (
The land continues to burn after Obsidian Fireheart has left the battlefield))
(S)
Inferno Titan (6/6, R: ~ gains +1/+0 until end of turn, whenever ~ enters the battlefield or attacks, it deals 3 damage divided as you choose among one, two, or three target creatures and/or players)
Graveyard: Mountain,
Pathmaker Initiate, Searing Spear, Mountain, Tormenting Voice
Exile:
----------------------------------------------------------------------
rokapoke: 24 30?
Hand: 1
Library: 47
Battlefield:
(T,T,U,U,U) Plains x5
(U)
Aerial Responder (6
/7 from ctrs; Flying, vigilance, lifelink) *4 +1/+1 ctr*
(S)
Youthful Knight (
3/2, First strike) *1 +1/+1 ctr*
Graveyard: Vizier of Deferment,
Doomed Traveler, Gideon's Lawkeeper, Aerial Responder, Lightwielder Paladin
Exile: