Well, at least temporarily I'm back on my desktop. I didn't really want to update your characters on my laptop and have to transfer everything back again, as I am lazy. I'll distribute the treasure like this tentatively, and if anyone wants to change it, let me know...
Throg: Lifestone of Ashraz, Bane Sword (Orcs), Blessed Sword
Dorgath: Enchanted Shield, Crossbow of Swiftness, Elf-Biter, Helm of the Dragonslayer
Carrow: Elf Shield, Dawnstone, Bane Sword (Goblins)
Kelgar can't really use any of it anyway and I've pretty much given up on Melkor returning to this anyway. Technically Throg won't be able to use most of this either once he gets more chaos stuff, but for now he's still human enough to benefit from these magic items. Everyone has some gear options now, so let me know what should be equipped by default now...
Dorgath's chain armor doesn't provide as much protection as the Enchanted Shield, so I'll assume he'll unequip his armor and switch to the shield. Dorgath can keep the Old Helmet he found in Karak Azgal in either case. For his weapon, he has two major axe options. Elf-Biter, Axe of Gromm ignores armor and once other modifiers are deducted (mostly Toughness, but some opponents have other forms of protection that can absorb damage), does double damage. Dorgath's Great Axe of Smiting deals an additional 1D6 damage on a to-hit roll of 5+ and also has a dwarven guildmasters rune that causes it to ignore 1 point of armor. The crossbow isn't much use yet, since no one has any crossbow bolts handy, but it might be worth equipping later. Dorgath also has a Skull Wand of Kaloth (some weird deal with charges that can't be replenished and it can instantly kill monsters if a charge is used up), Relic Blade (+1 to hit), a Blessed Sword (only misses on a to-hit roll of 2 or lower), a Sword of Might (+1 Strength), and a Sword of Defiance (+3 Toughness). He can only use his special ability (Great Axe Attack) with an axe.
Throg has his Axe of Might Striking and a bunch of swords to choose from as weaponry. He's usually been wielding a Sword of Defiance in his off-hand for the Toughness bonus, so I'll assume that continues for now. Let me know which weapon you want to actually use. I'm too lazy to type them all up right now. If you didn't keep track of them, I'll list them when I wake up. Spiderman is the only one that gets the full list. Spiderman get special treatment because he has almost a million posts.
Carrow has some swords too. I'll also list those later if you want. Some of them are pretty good I think. I'll assume that he defaults to Eltharion's Bow, but that if he goes melee he'll try to put the bow away and switch to a sword of some sort and his new Elf Shield. Good night.