The "Let's Design a Set Together" Game

Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Can you say cantrip?

Mollify 2WU
Instant
Remove target Artifact or Enchantment from the game.
Draw a card during the next turns upkeep'



Well? Am I just screwing it up?
 
Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Disappearing Ink
3UW
Enchantment
1UW: put a -1/-0 ink counter on target creature, it can only attack or block if it is the only attacker or blocker.
1UW: Put a -0/-1 ink counter on target creature, it can only attack or block if another creature is attacking or blocking.




Not sure about this one, could it be a creature with this ability?
 
R

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
I like the concept of turning it into a creature


Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters on them can't attack if there is another attacker.
Creatures with ink counters on them can't blocker if there is another blocker.
1UW: put a -1/-0 ink counter on target creature.
1UW: Put a -0/-1 ink counter on target creature.
2/4

Ransac, cpa trash man
 
Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters can only attack or block alone..
1UW: put a -1/-0 ink counter on target creature.
1UW: Put a -0/-1 ink counter on target creature.
2/4
Uncommon
It's black cloud obscures and isolates it's enemies

How is this? I got the wording from Ember Beast (sort of)
The creature is better, since the enchantment may have been to good.
 
L

Limited

Guest
Wouldn't the first ability be enough? I kinda think the concept of a -1/-0 counter with a name (ink) is weird.

How about:
Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters get -1/-0 and can only attack or block alone..
1UW: put a Ink counter on target creature.
2/4

This removes the ability of the Ink Counters being cumulative, which seems more appropriate.
Onions?
 
Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Limited said:
Wouldn't the firs ability be enough? I kinda think the concept of a -1/-0 counter with a name (ink) is weird.

How about:
Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters get -1/-0 and can only attack or block alone..
1UW: put a Ink counter on target creature.
2/4

This removes the ability of the Ink Counters being cumulative, which seems more appropriate.
Onions?
Click to expand...
But now there is no choice of the two different counters and less usefulness.
Also, the idea was to have the counters be cumulative, slow creature removal.
Maybe the creature should only be a 1/3.
 
R

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
I see what Oversoul is saying. The -0/-1 counter thing could prove abusive.

But, the way that it's worded right now only let's one counter per creature be worth something. If we work with THAT limitation, the creature SHOULD gain -1/-1.

Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters get -1/-1 and can only attack or block alone..
1UW: put a Ink counter on target creature.
2/4
 
Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
Ransac said:
I see what Oversoul is saying. The -0/-1 counter thing could prove abusive.

But, the way that it's worded right now only let's one counter per creature be worth something. If we work with THAT limitation, the creature SHOULD gain -1/-1.

Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters get -1/-1 and can only attack or block alone..
1UW: put a Ink counter on target creature.
2/4
Click to expand...
You two do realize that when the squid leaves play the ink counters don't give -1/-1 anymore?

Explain to me how a -0/-1 counter can get abusive but a -1/-1 can't, I'm a little confuised here.

I could just go with the -0/-1 ink counter
 
R

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
Well, it's abusive the original way. With no limit on how many counters to give out, it's ability is better than Masticore's 1 damage to creatures. But, limiting it to 1 per creature, -1/-1 ain't so bad.

Ransac, cpa trash man
 
Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
I want the abusiveness....... Put a tap function on it and make it slow creature removal too..... hahahahaha.......... I'm just not good at the maniacal laughing.....

Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters can only attack or block alone..
1UW, T: put a -0/-1 Ink counter on target creature.
2/4


This way the attacking/blocking restriction will go away with the squid, but the counters stay.
 
R

Ransac

CPA Trash Man
Mooseman said:
I want the abusiveness....... Put a tap function on it and make it slow creature removal too..... hahahahaha.......... I'm just not good at the maniacal laughing.....

Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters can only attack or block alone..
1UW, T: put a -0/-1 Ink counter on target creature.
2/4


This way the attacking/blocking restriction will go away with the squid, but the counters stay.
Click to expand...
If you give it the tap function, it would definitely warrant -1/-1. And Perhaps lowering the activation cost.


Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters can only attack or block alone..
UW, T: put a -1/-1 Ink counter on target creature.
2/4


Ransac, cpa trash man
 
Mooseman

Mooseman

Isengar Tussle
OK but how about just colorless, since it taps too.


Sticky-Ink Squid
3UW
Creature- Squid
Creatures with ink counters can only attack or block alone..
2, T: put a -1/-1 Ink counter on target creature.
2/4
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top